I’ve been trying to post blog entries about shows that I’ve seen before I see reviews of those shows by others. By doing this, I hope to both calibrate my eye as well as to declare my opinions untainted by the views of professional art critics. Due to a busy schedule, though, I wasn’t able to write up this report on the J.M.W. Turner show at the Metropolitan Museum of Art (through Sep 21) prior to seeing the review by Roberta Smith in the New York Times. She managed to capture my impressions of the show exceedingly well:
“The Metropolitan Museum of Art’s ‘J.M.W. Turner’ is a beast of a show. With nearly 150 works in oil and watercolor spanning more than half a century, it will either win you over or wear you out. Or it will alternate, gallery by gallery, or wall by wall, as the art swings between overblown and moving, inspired and mechanical.” [Roberta Smith]
This is precisely the way you feel as you go through the show. You see one piece of inspired, creative, brushy, abstracted mood, followed by rather boring, repetitive, flat seascape. Having long admired the two large Turner paintings in The Frick Collection’s west gallery, I was expecting more work along those lines, beautifully capturing light and reflection. I must admit that I hadn’t realized that Turner was so very… maritime. If scenes of boats thrashing about in storm-tossed waters don’t do it for you, you’ll get tired of this show rather quickly.
Given that many of the works are expressive seascapes with brushy paint, it was surprising that so many of the surfaces of these paintings were relatively flat. Not much in the way of crusty paint peaking off the canvas.
My favorite painting in the show was probably Saltash with Water Ferry (1811), which was beautifully composed and rendered and had a compelling mixture of crisp and soft edges. This was one of the few paintings where, upon closer examination, the figures didn’t look cartoonish. In most of the other works that include figures, it seems as if Turner couldn’t quite decide how much detail he should include.
It’s worth seeing this show, as it’s the first major retrospective of Turner in America and a chance to see a good chunk of his output all at once. But one final quote from Roberta Smith: “It is almost as if his drive to capture nature or history in motion was so intense that it didn’t leave room for anyone else, including the viewer. Maybe that’s why despite all his hard work and even the majesty of his vision, you can emerge from this exhibition impressed but oddly untouched, even chilled.”